Rural Hub

Cereals Live 2020: Rethinking the arable rotation

3 mins

Arable growers may need to rethink their arable rotation as they strive to improve productivity in an environmentally sustainable way.

One of the biggest questions currently facing farmers is how they can adapt their systems to deal with the phasing out of Basic Payments and the introduction of the Environmental Land Management System (ELMS).

Growers are facing the loss of the £230/ha BPS payment, which will be phased out between 2021-2028, along with the practical management challenges posed by more frequent weather extremes and a breakcrop crisis because of the inconsistency of OSR.

The industry is facing a collection of factors which will require significant changes for many farming businesses.

Data from more than 200 farms, which took part in an AHDB Farmbench exercise facilitated by Strutt & Parker during 2019, shows the potential for improvements on many farms. The data showed that the top 10% of producers had a whole farm net margin of £676/ha (£273/acre) compared to a group average of £288/ha (£116/acre).

Whilst a proportion of variation can always be attributed to soil type and geography, there is a significant management impact and there are a number of factors within a farmer’s control which would help to improve financial performance.

These include greater collaboration to form economies of scale, adoption of new technologies and greater attention to detail across the rotation to find marginal gains.

This attention to detail includes looking at the rotation, with a focus on growing profitable break crops to maximise first wheats.

This is an issue in the spotlight with many growers now feeling the risks of growing oilseed rape are too high. Possible alternatives include pulses, oats, linseed, but there are also some whole field Countryside Stewardship options available under mid-tier such as the two-year sown legume fallow (AB15).

This option produces a gross margin of around £450/ha* after seed costs, compared to 2019 harvest results of £535/ha for winter/spring beans and £578/ha for winter/spring oats.

While on paper this may not seem to be better financially than some commercial crops, an AB15 crop would offer consistency and a lower risk of failure and vulnerability to weather extremes – therefore balancing risk and reward. It also provides a wealth of pollen and nectar source for pollinators and food source for farmland birds.

Other environmental options worthy of inclusion in the arable rotation include AB2 Basic Over Winter Stubble, AB14 Harvested Low Input Cereal, AB6 Enhanced Overwinter Stubble, GS4 Legume and Herb Rich Sward.

Embracing some of these options into a balanced arable rotation will deliver a number of environmental benefits while still facilitating the production of high-quality crops on our farms.

  • George Badger, farming consultant in the Oxford office of Strutt & Parker, will be one of the speakers during the ‘Adapting to ELMS’ webinar on 10 June from 11.45am to 12.30pm where he will be looking at how growers will need to adapt to a changing policy framework and how best to incorporate environmental ‘crops’ into the mix

Cereals LIVE 2020 is a free virtual event taking place on the 10th & 11th June 2020 on the Cereals website, to access the interactive visitor experience and exhibitor led content, register here


*Excludes a potential fixed cost saving which has not been shown for AB15 vs conventional crops, but would be farm specific depending on whether labour and machinery overheads can be reallocated to alternative enterprises.

Beans: £535/ha Gross Margin in 2019, from 94 growers of winter and spring beans from S&P Farmbench. Oats: £578/ha Gross Margin in 2019, from 65 growers of winter and spring oats from S&P Farmbench

George Badger
Senior Associate Director, Rural
Send a message to George Badger
3 mins

Related Articles


Managing health and safety risks during harvest 2020

Farmers are required to assess and manage Covid-19 risks during the harvest period as part of their wider legal responsibility to protect the health and safety of their farmworkers. Farm businesses have continued to operate throughout the coronavirus outbreak, with social distancing and hygiene measures in place, but the run up to harvest is a […]

Top tips for making a mid-tier CSS application

Farmers still have enough time to make an application for mid-tier Countryside Stewardship for an agreement with a 1 January 2021 start date. Requests for an online application pack must be made by 30 June, with the deadline for applications to be submitted being 31 July. The benefits of a mid-tier CSS agreement include locking […]

Regional Round-up of Harvest Prospects and Trends for Cropping in 2021

Strutt & Parker’s farming consultants offer a regional insight into crop prospects for harvest 2020 and how growers are approaching the 2021 cropping season. Common themes and key messages: Caution about selling too much grain forward, because of pessimistic outlook for yields. Growers should see significant savings in fungicide spend because of the dry 2020 […]

Key Considerations for Crop Planning for Harvest 2021

After a busy spring, now is the time for farmers to reflect on the past year and assess how to get their rotations back on track after an incredibly challenging 12 months. Our clients and most growers will have a draft cropping plan for next year, but there still remains some flex in this depending […]
9 mins

Talk to us

Want to talk to us about our rural specialisms? Send us a message and we will make sure it gets to the right person.

Please write your name
Please write a message

Sign up

Sign up to be notified when we launch new publications so you’re always ahead of the research.

Please write your name
Please write a correct email address
Send me updates about
Please tick a box